This week

The Price of Life

000

In 1927, Julien Benda named a betrayal most people still have not recognised. The intellectuals, he argued, had abandoned their vocation. They had stopped serving truth and begun serving politics. They traded the eternal for the immediate, the universal for the tribal. He called it la trahison des clercs.

The treason has changed form. It is no longer nationalism that captures the thinking class. It is the platform. The algorithm. The invitation to convert every thought into content, every conviction into engagement, every silence into absence.

I read Benda slowly, in an edition that resists speed. His sentences are long. His examples are unfashionable. He cannot be skimmed. That is part of his value. He offers nothing optimisable.

Benda understood that the true intellectual lives outside what he called "the real": the domain of material advantage, political passion, strategic visibility. The price of that life is peace. Comfort. Belonging. The rewards that come from aligning yourself with whatever the crowd currently honours.

For two thousand years, he wrote, humanity did evil but honoured good. That contradiction held open a rift, and through it, civilisation entered the world.

The outriders maintain the rift.

Responses.

Join for free to respond.

By joining you confirm you are 13 or over.

Privacy · Terms

Continue reading.

A ↺ A

Reading offline. Pages you have opened are still here.