In 1953 Pauline Oliveros (1932 to 2016), an American composer and accordionist, was given a tape recorder for her twenty-first birthday. She set it up at her apartment window and found the microphone had caught sounds she had not heard while it ran. Her response was a rule for herself: listen to everything all the time, and remind yourself when you are not. She says the reminders were still arriving forty-six years later. The practice she built from it, Deep Listening, took its name from a 1988 recording she made with Stuart Dempster and Panaiotis in the Fort Worden cistern at Port Townsend, Washington, where a sound hangs for about forty-five seconds. Quantum Listening is the essay she wrote in 1999 setting out a theory drawn from that practice. Ignota reissued it in 2022 with a foreword by Laurie Anderson, illustrations by Aura Satz and an introduction by IONE, the poet and psychotherapist who joined her as a Deep Listening instructor.
Her starting point is a distinction most of us skip. Hearing is involuntary, and we can hear without listening; listening is a voluntary process that, through training and experience, produces culture. How we listen, she writes, creates our life, and listening is the basis of all culture. The publisher calls the book a manifesto for listening as activism and ties it to the anti-war movements of the 1960s. Her own account is more local: by 1970, teaching non-music students at the University of California, San Diego, she had begun composing Sonic Meditations that anyone could join whether or not they read music, and says they gave her work a whole new direction.
The "quantum" in the title is the hard part. Oliveros describes two modes of listening, focal and global, and the interdependence of the two. Quantum Listening, she says, is listening in all sense modes for the least possible differences while perceiving the whole and sensing change, and she puts it in a single line: the Quantum Listener "listens to listening". The physics arrives as analogy. She quotes P. Steven Petersen's The Quantum Tai Chi (1996) on fields, then writes "analogously" of the whole field of sound, in which the listener and the sounds co-create form and each is transformed by the other. If you do not listen in this expanded way, she says, the field disappears into the background, attention narrows and the potential lessens, which she likens to the collapse of the wave function. My reading is that the comparisons describe attention that watches itself, and what happens to it when it stops.
She is not beyond argument. Writing in ArtReview in May 2022, En Liang Khong finds her prose drawn to a grander spiritual ambit, and her pursuit of heightened sensing more persuasive in her music than in her writing. He makes a sharper point about what has happened to the idea since: attentive listening has never been more easily commodified and co-opted, from a presidential campaign's listening tour to business coaches who teach Deep Listening as a leadership skill. That is a fair warning. A practice that can be packaged and sold has already been captured, and the only defence is to keep doing it as practice.
This is why it belongs on 000, and why it is a practice I keep. I listen this way myself, most of all in rooms built for it: listening bars and other places where the music, and the DJ, are the point. I am not the only one on 000 who does. In Episode 2 of the 000 Creator Series, @sndyvibes, asked where her inspiration comes from, points to what is around her: the train, the cars, something flapping overhead, "just sounds of life". She does not call it deep listening, but what I hear in it is a form of meditation she is already practising. It matters to hear that from a DJ, who sits at the heart of deep listening, always searching for the next sound to manipulate. Oliveros saw the cost coming, though she was writing about machine sound. She argues that the devaluation of hearing through unconsciousness and ignorance has produced a serious imbalance, that suppression of listening follows, and that how we attend to the imbalance will shape human values. My extension is that the same logic holds for attention now: most of what reaches us is built to be heard, in her sense, arriving without our consent, and listening is the one form of attention that is still voluntary. I think that if more of us listened this way, the whole experience of listening would be turned on its head, for the better. So close your eyes. Every room holds sonic fields most of us never find, because we lean on sight, and for a few minutes at a time it is worth putting that literacy down. When you open them, write down every sound you found, mark the ones you chose to notice, and ask how many were left to the room to choose for you.
Sources: Pauline Oliveros, Quantum Listening (Ignota, 2022), pp. 33, 35, 37, 42, 52 and 53, and her 1999 essay of the same title; En Liang Khong, ArtReview, 30 May 2022; Sonic Field, 16 September 2022; Wikipedia, Pauline Oliveros.
Responses.
Received. Thank you.