This week

Literature

The written word.

Quantum Listening

In 1953 Pauline Oliveros (1932 to 2016), an American composer and accordionist, was given a tape recorder for her twenty-first birthday. She set it up at her apartment window and found the microphone had caught sounds she had not heard while it ran. Her response was a rule for herself: listen to everything all the time, and remind yourself when you are not. She says the reminders were still arriving forty-six years later. The practice she built from it, Deep Listening, took its name from a 1988 recording she made with Stuart Dempster and Panaiotis in the Fort Worden cistern at Port Townsend, Washington, where a sound hangs for about forty-five seconds. Quantum Listening is the essay she wrote in 1999 setting out a theory drawn from that practice. Ignota reissued it in 2022 with a foreword by Laurie Anderson, illustrations by Aura Satz and an introduction by IONE, the poet and psychotherapist who joined her as a Deep Listening instructor.

Her starting point is a distinction most of us skip. Hearing is involuntary, and we can hear without listening; listening is a voluntary process that, through training and experience, produces culture. How we listen, she writes, creates our life, and listening is the basis of all culture. The publisher calls the book a manifesto for listening as activism and ties it to the anti-war movements of the 1960s. Her own account is more local: by 1970, teaching non-music students at the University of California, San Diego, she had begun composing Sonic Meditations that anyone could join whether or not they read music, and says they gave her work a whole new direction.

The "quantum" in the title is the hard part. Oliveros describes two modes of listening, focal and global, and the interdependence of the two. Quantum Listening, she says, is listening in all sense modes for the least possible differences while perceiving the whole and sensing change, and she puts it in a single line: the Quantum Listener "listens to listening". The physics arrives as analogy. She quotes P. Steven Petersen's The Quantum Tai Chi (1996) on fields, then writes "analogously" of the whole field of sound, in which the listener and the sounds co-create form and each is transformed by the other. If you do not listen in this expanded way, she says, the field disappears into the background, attention narrows and the potential lessens, which she likens to the collapse of the wave function. My reading is that the comparisons describe attention that watches itself, and what happens to it when it stops.

She is not beyond argument. Writing in ArtReview in May 2022, En Liang Khong finds her prose drawn to a grander spiritual ambit, and her pursuit of heightened sensing more persuasive in her music than in her writing. He makes a sharper point about what has happened to the idea since: attentive listening has never been more easily commodified and co-opted, from a presidential campaign's listening tour to business coaches who teach Deep Listening as a leadership skill. That is a fair warning. A practice that can be packaged and sold has already been captured, and the only defence is to keep doing it as practice.

This is why it belongs on 000, and why it is a practice I keep. I listen this way myself, most of all in rooms built for it: listening bars and other places where the music, and the DJ, are the point. I am not the only one on 000 who does. In Episode 2 of the 000 Creator Series, @sndyvibes, asked where her inspiration comes from, points to what is around her: the train, the cars, something flapping overhead, "just sounds of life". She does not call it deep listening, but what I hear in it is a form of meditation she is already practising. It matters to hear that from a DJ, who sits at the heart of deep listening, always searching for the next sound to manipulate. Oliveros saw the cost coming, though she was writing about machine sound. She argues that the devaluation of hearing through unconsciousness and ignorance has produced a serious imbalance, that suppression of listening follows, and that how we attend to the imbalance will shape human values. My extension is that the same logic holds for attention now: most of what reaches us is built to be heard, in her sense, arriving without our consent, and listening is the one form of attention that is still voluntary. I think that if more of us listened this way, the whole experience of listening would be turned on its head, for the better. So close your eyes. Every room holds sonic fields most of us never find, because we lean on sight, and for a few minutes at a time it is worth putting that literacy down. When you open them, write down every sound you found, mark the ones you chose to notice, and ask how many were left to the room to choose for you.

Sources: Pauline Oliveros, Quantum Listening (Ignota, 2022), pp. 33, 35, 37, 42, 52 and 53, and her 1999 essay of the same title; En Liang Khong, ArtReview, 30 May 2022; Sonic Field, 16 September 2022; Wikipedia, Pauline Oliveros.

Responses.

The Shield of Achilles

W.H. Auden's The Shield of Achilles (1955) is arguably his most tightly unified collection, and won the US National Book Award for Poetry in 1956. It gathers work from 1951 to 1954 into three movements: the "Bucolics" sequence, a set of miscellaneous middle poems, and the closing "Horae Canonicae" sequence, which restages the Crucifixion across the medieval prayer hours. The title poem sits between the two sequences, and is the hinge the whole book turns on.

The poem is a direct provocation to Homer. Book 18 of the Iliad contains one of the most celebrated passages in Western literature: Hephaestus forging Achilles a new shield, decorated with a kind of cosmography of civilisation, cities at peace and at war, a wedding, a harvest, dancing. Auden restages the exact same scene, Thetis watching over the smith's shoulder, hoping to see that same abundance for her son, and refuses her, three times over.

Short, three-line stanzas voice Thetis's expectation; the longer stanzas describe what Hephaestos actually forges instead: a flat, featureless plain, ranked columns of marching men, and, most memorably, a bureaucratised execution: "Barbed wire enclosed an arbitrary spot / Where bored officials lounged (one cracked a joke) / And sentries sweated for the day was hot: / A crowd of ordinary decent folk / Watched from without and neither moved nor spoke." The officials are bored, not monstrous. The crowd is decent, and does nothing.

The poem closes by turning the irony back on Thetis herself, forging a weapon for a killer: "Iron-hearted, man-slaying Achilles / Who would not live long." Her dismay is naive on its own terms. The grim modern shield is arguably the more honest object, truer to what Achilles is actually for than the pastoral idyll she wanted.

000's reading: Auden isn't arguing that war is hell, he's arguing something colder, that modern violence has become procedural, administered rather than heroic, and that the old civic imagery Homer used to hold a culture together no longer applies. Written in 1952, close enough to the war and the camps, and inside the first nuclear arms race, to read as a direct argument about what industrialised violence does to inherited ideals.

Responses.

Civilization: How We All Became American

Régis Debray's Civilization: How We All Became American, published by Verso in 2019 and translated by David Fernbach, appeared two years after its French original, Civilisation: comment nous sommes devenus américains, published by Gallimard in 2017. The premise sounds like a provocation and turns out to be an argument: that the twentieth century's real victor was not a country but a way of organising time, space and appetite, and that way now has a name, and the name is American.

Debray is an unlikely person to make this argument from inside a paperback. Born in Paris in 1940 and trained at the École Normale Supérieure under Louis Althusser, he was teaching philosophy in Havana by the late 1960s and was in Bolivia with Che Guevara's guerrilla column soon after. Arrested in 1967, he was sentenced to thirty years in prison; an international campaign, with Sartre and de Gaulle among the names attached to it, secured his release in 1970. He returned to France, and from 1981 served as François Mitterrand's adviser on foreign affairs, tasked partly with loosening France's dependence on the United States. He is also the inventor of mediology, his own discipline for studying how cultural meaning is carried materially across time, not just believed. Nobody arrives at this book's argument casually.

The distinction the whole book turns on is old, but Debray restates it with some force: a culture constructs sites, he writes, a civilisation builds roads. Culture is rooted and particular, a soil that produces one wine and not another. Civilisation is a network: it does not need to be loved, only connected to, and it spreads by armies, fleets and, he notes, drones as readily as by ideas. He traces the word "civilisation" to Mirabeau and Voltaire, who coined it as the Enlightenment's exit door from Barbarism, and from there to the later German split between Kultur, living and particular, and Zivilisation, portable and inert, a distinction he credits Lévi-Strauss with restating in anthropological terms: culture as the attitudes and skills a society teaches its members, learned rather than built.

Debray gives the mechanism its own grammar, three terms in a determining sequence: imperium, the empire itself, emprise, the hold or influence it exerts once the conquering stops, and empreinte, the imprint or trace left behind after both have gone. "A supremacy is established," he writes, "when the imprint survives the impress, and the impress the imperium." Rome is one of the cases he tests it against. It reads, unavoidably, as a description of the exact order in which he thinks American power is now spending itself: empire first, then influence, and last of all, longest of all, the imprint.

Having drawn the line, Debray spends the rest of the book arguing that one side has swallowed the other. His index case is a single reversal: in 1900, he writes, an American of taste was a European in exile; by 2000, a fashionable European is a frustrated American, or one still waiting on a visa. He reduces American civilisation to three fetishes, space, image and happiness, set against a European civilisation of time and writing, and points to "globish", a word for the American-English vocabulary that has colonised every other European tongue, as the symptom that confirms the diagnosis. His one offered way out looks backward rather than forward: Vienna at the cusp of the twentieth century, excluded from the German Reich, its own empire visibly declining, yet still a hothouse for art and literature. A demoted culture, he suggests, can still be a fertile one. He does not sound entirely convinced by his own consolation.

000's interest in the sites-and-roads line runs past Debray's own argument, which is about geopolitics, not feeds. But a culture that constructs sites and a civilisation that builds roads is also a fair description of the difference between a body of work and a scroll: one is rooted somewhere and asks you to slow down for it, the other only wants you connected, moving. Debray isn't making that argument here. It is just difficult to read the line and not make it yourself.

Responses.

“ Debray is an unlikely person to make this argument from inside a paperback” - I didn’t get why

Gabs

Two things really... He spent his twenties fighting with Che Guevara in Bolivia, did thirty years for it, then ended up advising a French President, so his whole life was ACTION, and here is making his case in a more quiet paperback instead. That's one irony. The bigger one: the argument itself, that local culture is losing out to one big global way of life, sounds like something a conservative worried about lost tradition would say (i.e., MAGA), not a Marxist revolutionary. The politics and the argument are pulling in opposite directions. For me, that's the "unlikely person" part.

Michael

Answered Prayers

Truman Capote spent most of his adult life circling Answered Prayers. He signed the contract with Random House in 1966, describing it as his Proustian novel, the book that would account for everything he had seen among New York's monied class. He had seen quite a lot. By the time he arrived in Manhattan in the 1940s, he had already published Other Voices, Other Rooms and acquired the kind of celebrity that opened doors no ordinary talent could unlock. Babe Paley invited him to her table. C.Z. Guest, Gloria Guinness, Slim Keith. He listened, and he remembered.

The problem with Answered Prayers was precisely that. Four chapters appeared in Esquire across 1975 and 1976, and the consequences were severe. "La Cote Basque, 1965," published in November 1975, was the most incendiary: it reproduced confidences with enough precision that even slightly veiled identities were immediately transparent. The women who had trusted him felt, not without reason, that they had been used. Capote lost the social world the novel was meant to portray. The banishment was nearly total.

He died in 1984 with most of the manuscript missing. Only three chapters survive, collected here: Unspoiled Monsters, Kate McCloud, and La Cote Basque. Whether the missing chapters existed at all remains disputed. What is certain is that the narrator, P.B. Jones, provincial hustler and aspiring writer, is a projection of Capote's own ambition and self-contempt simultaneously. He knew what he was doing in those rooms. He also knew what it cost.

"I would prefer to own two really good forks rather than a dozen that are merely good." Miss Langman says this in the opening chapter. The line stays with you because it is the kind of remark Capote would have recorded immediately, recognising in it not snobbery but a very particular form of discipline: the refusal of sufficiency. Two forks. The best possible.

Read in the sun, in a park, with the afternoon doing whatever it wanted around you. The right conditions for a book about people who arranged their lives entirely around the question of how to live.

Responses.

The Natural Principles and Analogy of the Harmony of Form

David Ramsay Hay (1798-1866) published The Natural Principles and Analogy of the Harmony of Form in 1842, and it has been quietly ignored by the mainstream ever since. This is a mistake. Hay, an Edinburgh-trained artist, interior decorator, and colour theorist, made a claim so ambitious it bordered on the absurd: that the laws governing musical harmony also govern visual beauty, and that both can be reduced to mathematics.

His method is straightforward. He constructs an analogy between the three fundamental geometric shapes (the circle, the triangle, and the square) and the three foundational notes of the musical scale (the tonic, the mediant, and the dominant). When these shapes are superimposed, they produce visual harmony. When arranged in sequence, they produce visual melody. The resulting compositions can be evaluated by the simplicity and regularity of their proportions, just as a chord can be evaluated by the ratios between its frequencies.

Hay ascribes the superiority of ancient Greek art and architecture to their reliance on the Pythagorean system of harmonic numbers. The Parthenon, he argues, is not beautiful because the Greeks had superior taste. It is beautiful because they understood the mathematics of proportion and applied them with rigour. Beauty, in Hay's framework, is not subjective. It is structural. It can be derived, demonstrated, and reproduced.

This is where the book becomes dangerous, and interesting. If beauty is structural, then it is not a matter of opinion. It is a matter of knowledge. The person who understands harmonic proportion sees what others merely feel. The implication is that aesthetic education is not about cultivating sensitivity; it is about learning the rules that already govern perception.

The contemporary relevance is obvious, if unintended. Algorithmic recommendation systems operate on a crude version of this same logic: reduce beauty to pattern, pattern to data, data to prediction. The difference is that Hay sought to elevate the viewer's understanding, while the algorithm seeks to predict and exploit the viewer's response. Both assume beauty can be formalised. Only one respects the person looking.

Hay's prose is dense, his diagrams occasionally impenetrable, and his confidence in the universality of Pythagorean proportion is, by modern standards, overstated. But the core proposition endures: that beauty is not arbitrary, that proportion is not taste, and that the search for structural harmony is one of the most serious things a person can undertake.

Responses.

In the Shadow of the Gods

Dominic Lieven's In the Shadow of the Gods (Allen Lane, 2022) is a long book about a question most people never think to ask: what did it actually mean to be an emperor?

Not the mythology. Not the costumes. The mechanics. How did one person hold together a territory spanning thousands of miles, dozens of languages, and competing religions, without a single algorithm to model compliance? Lieven's answer threads through millennia, from Sargon of Akkad in the third millennium BCE to the collapse of the great European empires in the twentieth century, taking in Habsburg, Russian, Ottoman, Mughal, and Chinese rule along the way. Emperors, he argues, were the original systems architects. They built structures of loyalty, ritual, and bureaucratic dependency that functioned as governance long before anyone had a word for it.

The book moves chronologically but thinks thematically. Sacred monarchies in the ancient world. Steppe warrior-emperors whose legitimacy was earned in the field and lost the moment they stopped earning it. The Chinese Mandate of Heaven: a framework that made the emperor accountable to cosmic forces rather than to a populace, yet produced some of the most sophisticated administrative states in human history.

What makes Lieven's work relevant beyond the history shelf is its quiet argument about power and consent. Every empire he examines ran on a version of the same bargain: protection and order in exchange for obedience and tribute. The mechanisms of capture change (divine right, military threat, algorithmic recommendation) but the underlying architecture does not. Someone builds the system. Someone else lives inside it. The question is always the same: who benefits from the arrangement, and who has forgotten they are inside one?

Lieven does not make this contemporary connection explicitly. He does not need to. A reader paying attention will make it themselves.

Responses.

Full archive
A ↺ A

Reading offline. Pages you have opened are still here.